Participation and Civic Education in International Comparison

"Democracy ... a challenge" - although the poster shown here, created by the US administration around 1940, is quite old, it couldn't be more up to date. Autocratic tendencies seem to be on the rise again worldwide, even in the oldest democracy in the world. And it turns out: democracy is hard work.
In the educational sector in Germany, this is referred to as "Demokratiebildung" (democracy education), but also as "politische Bildung" (political education) or "staatsbürgerlicher Erziehung" (civic education). In English-speaking countries, you often hear the term "civic education", but also "education for democratic citizenship" or "political education". This dossier will focus on these topics from an international perspective: It offers freely accessible information on the subject of democracy education worldwide.
Among other things, it will also examine the question of how democracy education can actually contribute to a better democratic society. In any case, there is hope, as a 2024 academic paper on the topic of "reversing autocratisation" shows: "A key finding is that 48% of all episodes of autocratization become democratic turnarounds, which increases to 70% when focusing on the last 30 years. The vast majority of democratic turnarounds (93%) lead to restored or even improved levels of democracy." (Nord; Angiolillo; Lundstedt et al., 2024)
You can find out whether and to what extent democracy education can contribute to this reversal in the article and in the information compiled here.
Overviews
Overview maps and graphics
Mapping Civic Education in Europe
Including the reports "Great Expectations: Demands and Realities of Civic Education in Europe" (2023) and "From ‘civic deserts’ to civic cohesion" (2022)
THE CIVICS, a pan-European non-profit organisationAtlas of European Values (interactive)
The website offers an interactive world map of the results of the study on European values, including a democracy index and other questions and values ​​on the topic of democracy. There is also teaching material, theoretical background information or a framework curriculum. Furthermore, you can find two publications from 2022 so far: Volume 1 presents the results of the study in written form; Volume 2 offers discussions and interpretations of the results.
European Values Study > European Values in Education (EVALUE)Map of organisations with expertise in education and youth participation
International Democracy Community / Democracy International (Germany-based NGO)
Country reports and profiles
Country Profiles: Citizenship Education Around the World
Federal Agency for Civic Education (FACE), Germany- Country Reports (civic education)
Civic education in various, mainly European countries.
JSSE - Journal of Social Science Education; Bielefeld University > Faculty of Sociology
Overview studies
International Civic and Citizenship Education Study (ICCS)
starting in 2009
International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement (IEA)CIVED - Civic Education Study
1999-2000, forerunner of the ICCS
Humboldt University of Berlin & IEAInfluences of the IEA Civic and Citizenship Education Studies. Practice, Policy, and Research Across Countries and Regions (2021)
with examples from Latin America, Europe, North America, Asia
Editors: Barbara Malak-Minkiewicz, Judith Torney-PurtaEuropean Values Study (EVS)
Under "About EVS > Research Topics > Politics" you can find some results on the topic of democracy. The EVS publishes, among other things, the Atlas of European Values (​​(as part of its project European Values in Education, EVALUE)
Tilburg University, Netherlands > Department of Sociology > European Values StudyWorld Values Survey
The site seems a bit old-fashioned and the study results are also presented in a rather scientific manner. Nevertheless, it offers interesting insights into the global, country-specific prioritisation of various values ​​relating to democracy. This is made a little clearer, for example, in the Inglehart-Welzel Cultural Map (under Findings & Insights).
World Values Survey Association / Institute for Comparative Survey Research, Vienna, Austria / Institute for Future Studies, Stockholm, Sweden
Overview texts
Moulding democratic citizens: democracy and education in modern European history – an introduction (2022)
In: European Review of History: Revue Européenne d’histoire 29(6): 859–883
Wagner; KösslerTeaching Civic Engagement Globally (2021)
with examples from Brazil, China, UK, Ireland, Egypt, New Zealand, Belize, Guatemala, Greece, Singapore, Russia, Gambia, Senegal, South Africa, Germany, Mauritius, Finland
American Political Science Association (APSA)Citizenship education in teacher training: A systematic review (2024)
In: Journal of Social Science Education Vol. 23 No. 3
Pérez-Rodríguez; Navarro-Medina; de-Alba-FernándezChallenges for European teachers when assessing student learning to promote democratic citizenship competences (2023)
In: Journal of Social Science Education Vol. 22 No. 3
Paaske; Mohammad-Roe; Smets et al.Influences of the IEA Civic and Citizenship Education Studies. Practice, Policy, and Research Across Countries and Regions (2021)
with examples from Latin America, Europe, North America, Asia
Hrsg.: Barbara Malak-Minkiewicz, Judith Torney-PurtaPolitische Partizipation im internationalen Vergleich : eine quantitative Analyse (2020)
master's thesis
Anja Rainer
University of Graz, Faculty of Social and Economic Sciences, Institute of SociologyFormación docente en competencias ciudadanas globales: una revisión sistemática de literatura (2023)
(Teacher preparation in global citizenship competencies: A systematic literature review)
In: Sinéctica no.60 ene./jun. 2023, Epub 26-Jun-2023
Article in Spanish with an English abstract
Díaz Méndez; Gallardo Córdova; Velarde Camaqui
Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Occidente, Departamento de Educación y Valores, Universidad Jesuita de Guadalajara (Mexiko)
Statistics & reports
Our World in Data > Topics: Human Rights & Democracy > Democracy
The overview page of the portal "Our World in Data" offers all statistics, diagrams (many interactive), graphics, texts and more on the topic of democracy from an international perspective at a glance. Among other things, there is also the Democracy Data Explorer. The data can usually be filtered by country, among other things.
University of Oxford; Global Change Data Lab; Oxford Martin Programme on Global DevelopmentDemocracy Reports
The report has been published annually since 2017. Each report has a focus topic and a "Country Scores" section that indicates how democratic countries around the world are considered to be. In recent years, there have also been increasing analyses of autocracies, which get compared to democracies.
V-Dem Institute (Varieties of Democracy Project)Learning to live together - Report on the State of Citizenship and Human Rights Education in Europe (2017)
The report is part of the second cycle of reviews of the implementation of the Council of Europe Charter on Education for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights (Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)7).
Council of EuropeState of democracy, human rights and the rule of law (ab 2020)
Reports from 2014 till 2019 can be viewed in the Internet archive.
Annual report of the Secretary General of the Council of EuropeOECD Better Life Index > Civic EngagementCivic engagement in OECD countries is measured using two criteria: the involvement of interest groups in policy development and voter turnout.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)D10.1 Country Reports - Education
Country reports on civic education from the Horizon 2020 project "De-Radicalisation in Europe and Beyond: Detect, Resolve, Re-integrate". Countries reported on: Turkey, Italy, Germany, France, Bosnia.
D.Rad project; The Glasgow Caledonian University, UK
Networks, associations, organisations
Association of Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Europe
The first School of Political Studies was founded in Moscow in 1992 by a group of civil society activists committed to promoting democratic values.
See also the page Council of Europe Schools of Political Studies.
Council of EuropeEducation for Democracy
Including links to the "Reference Framework of Competences for Democratic Culture", information on the Steering Committee for Education - CDEDU and recommendations from the Committee of Ministers.
See also the section „Youth for Democracy“
Council of Europe: Civil Society Portal > Democracy > Democratic ParticipationDARE Network - Democracy and Human Rights Education in Europe
Including the Competendo Digital Toolbox and publications like Learning democracy with children aged 8-12, Vol 1 & 2 (Handbook for Educators).
European network for Education for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights Education (DARE)Map of organisations with expertise in education and youth participation
International Democracy Community / Democracy International (Germany-based NGO)International Network on Civic Education
Unfortunately, the network has not had its own website since the first conference in 2022 (as of January 2025) and only refers to LinkedIn as a platform for networking, which is not freely accessible. There is a short report on the 2022 conference.
Konrad Adenauer Foundation, GermanyEuropean Training and Research Centre for Human Rights and Democracy (ETC)
The center has two different websites. The one linked in the title seems to offer more and more current information in the areas of research and news. Another website offers more and older publications and also current, but different news, but mainly in German. You can find a short "about us" and the annual reports in English.
University of Graz, AustriaEuropean Democratic Education Community (EUDEC)
Non-profit organisation that promotes democratic education. Members include schools, institutions and individuals across Europe.The European Wergeland Centre (EWC) - Educating for Democracy and Human Rights
The EWC is a resource center for education for intercultural understanding, human rights and democratic citizenship.
Council of Europe; Kingdom of Norway- Academia Ciudadana
The Citizens' Academy is an initiative of the Organization of Ibero-American States (OEI) with the Asociación Panameña de Debate (ASPADE) and the Fundación Eduardo Morgan (FUNDAMORGAN).
Organisation of Ibero-American States (OEI) Citizens and Diaspora Directorate (CIDO) > Civil Society Division
See also the section "Democracy, Law & Human Rights"
African UnionArab Network for Civic Education
The network includes 45 organisations from nine Arab countries: Egypt, Lebanon, Algeria, Iraq, Palestine, Jordan, Morocco, Yemen and Tunisia.Indonesian Pancasila and Citizenship Education Professional Association (AP3KnI)
Also called "Indonesia Association of Pancasila and Civic Education Profession (IAPCEP)." Publishes the freely accessible Jurnal PPKn and organises the Annual Civic Education Conference (ACEC). To switch to the English website, see the flags at the bottom left.International Democratic Education Network (IDEN)
The network is primarily committed to the democratic rights of children and to alternative schools in which children have more say. IDEN has been organising the IDEC (International Democratic Education Conference) since 1993 and offers a world map of people, organisations and schools in its network.
Reference frameworks & guidelines
- Charter on Education for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights Education (2010)
For recommendations within the Charter, see the section "Democracy and Human Dignity > Education Knowledge Hub > Resources > Legal instruments". There are also "Guidelines for Educators" (2013) on the Charter.
Council of Europe > Democracy and Human Dignity > Education for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights Education (EDC/HRE) - Reference Framework of Competences for Democratic Culture (RFCDC)
Including instructions for implementation, tools for self-reflection for teachers and many publications on the topic.
Council of Europe > Directorate General of Democracy and Human Dignity - Res Publica: An International Framework for Education in Democracy
Center for Civic Education (USA)
Manuals & tools for promoting democracy
- Competendo - The Digital Toolbox
Free & open toolbox for democracy education, digitalization and non-formal education.
DARE-Network - Democracy and Human Rights Education in Europe Living Democracy manuals
Designed as teaching materials for teachers, the handbooks were created by authors from different parts of Europe and cover the entire age range from primary to secondary school as well as extracurricular education.
Council of EuropeThe Little Big Handbook of Democracy
A handbook for young people with concrete advice and tips on democracy and civic education.
European Wergeland Centre (EWC)Listen – Act – Change - Council of Europe Handbook on children’s participation (2020)
The handbook is a contribution to the Council of Europe Strategy on the Rights of the Child (2016-2021). It is intended as a guide for professionals working for and with children.
Crowley; Larkins; Pinto; Council of Europe Children’s Rights Division- EDC/HRE Pack
The Education for democratic citizenship (EDC) and Human rights education package contains "publications specifically addressed to policy makers, teacher trainers, school directors, school inspectors, universities and civil society organisations."
Council of Europe - Defending Democracy against Illiberal Challengers - A Resource Guide [pdf]
The guide also contains "Tools for political education" in Chapter 3 (Guidelines, Political Education in Schools, Political Education for Adults).Varieties of Democracy Project (V-Dem Institute)
Human rights, democratic citizenship and interculturalism - Online and teaching resources
Freely accessible publications in PDF format on the topics of human rights, democratic citizenship and interculturalism.
Council of EuropeManual de Competencias Ciudadanas (2020)
Academia Ciudadana, Organisation of Ibero-American States (OEI)
Projects, programmes
Living Democracy - Living & Learning Democracy in schools and at home
The “Living Democracy” project offers free educational resources on democracy and human rights on its website. The resources are available in several European languages. The educational materials are created by educators from different countries and approved by the national authorities of the respective countries and the Council of Europe.
Council of Europe & Zurich University of Teacher Education (PHZH)European Year of Digital Citizenship Education 2025 - Empowering Learners for a Democratic Future
"How can we equip learners for a democratic future? How can we equip all learners with the necessary skills, values, attitudes and knowledge to navigate effectively in the digital world?" Answers to these questions will be found in projects and events surrounding the European Year of Digital Citizenship Education 2025. See also information Booklet and further information .
Council of EuropeEducation for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights Education (EDC/HRE) programme
With publications, teaching materials and more.
Council of Europe > Directorate General of Democracy ("DGII") > Directorate of Democratic Participation > Education DepartmentProjects on the topic of “democracy education” in the Erasmus+ project database
European Commission, Directorate-General for Education, Youth, Sport and CultureVarieties of Democracy Project (V-Dem Institute)
The project aims at conceptualising and measuring democracy. V-Dem distinguishes between five overarching democratic principles: electoral, liberal, participation, deliberation and egalitarian principles. It collects data to measure them. The data collected is used for publications, statistics, graphics and more.
University of Gothenburg, Sweden > Department of Political ScienceCivitas International Programs
The program offers exemplary civic education curricula in cooperation with organisations in the United States and 84 partner countries. In addition to producing teaching materials, another focus is on training teachers in Eastern Europe, the former Soviet Union, Africa, Asia, Latin America and the Caribbean, and the Middle East. See also the Research and Evaluation section for publications within the framework of Civitas.
Center for Civic Education (CIVICED), USA“Free to Speak - Safe to Learn” Democratic Schools for All (2017-2022)
The Democratic Schools Network, among others, emerged from the project.
Council of Europe"Education and Culture of Democracy" (ECUD) (2014-2016)
The project aimed to explore, using a human rights-based approach, the means to strengthen the commitment of higher education to a culture of democracy in European and Maghreb societies as an essential component of the quality of higher education.
Council of Europe
Freely accessible academic literature
Democracy and Human Dignity > Education > Publications
Including freely accessible publications on the topics of "Competences for Democratic Culture", "Digital Citizenship Education", "Living Democracy", "Democratic citizenship and intercultural dialogue".
Council of EuropeJournal of Social Science Education (JSSE)
Open access journal that focuses on democracy education, among other things. The website also contains country reports on "civic education" in various countries.
Bielefeld University > Faculty of SociologyEducation, Citizenship and Social Justice (Journal)
The journal regularly has single articles that are freely accessible, with a focus on democracy education.
The editors currently come from the United KingdomFreely accessible journal on the subject of democracy in the Electronic Journal Library (EZB)
Of course, you can also find non-freely accessible journals on the subject of democracy in the EZB. The EZB "is one of the most comprehensive freely accessible bibliographic databases on scientific electronic journals. In 2023, it had over 12 million title accesses and is used and processed by almost all major libraries in the German-speaking world." (Source: Wikipedia Germany)
University of Regensburg > University LibraryThe Road to Progressive Political Institutions: Revisiting the Link between Education and Democracy (2021)
In: World Values Research 13 (1): 1-37
Peyper; van Eyden; BlackmoreThe Case for Democracy: Does Democracy Have Dividends for Education? (2022) [pdf]
V-Dem Institute Policy Brief No. #35
Varieties of Democracy Project (V-Dem Institute); University of Gothenburg > Department of Political ScienceDo Democracies Provide Better Education? Revisiting the Democracy–Human Capital Link (2017)
In: World Development, Volume 94: 186-199
Dahlum; KnutsenThe Effect of Education on Democracy: Panel Data Analysis of High Income Countries (2019)
In: Universal Journal of Educational Research Vol. 7(11): 2425 – 2431
Karış; TandoğanEngaging young citizens - Civic education practices in the classroom and beyond (2022)
OECD Education Policy Perspectives No. 65Impact of democracy on literacy rate: A cross country study (2020)
In: International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science (2147-4478) 9(7): 204-211
Hosen; Paul; RosidApproaches to Civic Education in Africa (2011)
Helpdesk Research Report, Governance and Social Development Research Centre (GSDRC)
Freida M’CormackEthnic Composition and Democratic Values: A Global Investigation of Citizens’ Desire for Democracy, 1995–2014 (2023)
In: Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 29 (1): 21-38
Haseth; Holum; Jakobsen
Not freely accessible
- Education and democracy: New evidence from 161 countries (2018)
In: Economic Modelling, Volume 71: 59-67
The introduction and some excerpts from the various sections are freely accessible.
Apergis, Nicholas
Conferences and other events
NECE Festival - European festival of civic education 
Norway
Deadline for CfP 31.03.2025
Beginning 02.09.2025
"The NECE Festival is an annual European gathering that brings together stakeholders from civil society, politics, academia, media, and culture for an interactive and interdisciplinary exchange of ideas and actions. The festival is held in various European cities and focuses on a specific topic that is highly relevant to civic education." The festival took place for [...]
CONSULCON25 - Consul Conference 2025 
Spain
Beginning 04.02.2025
"The conference celebrates the 10-year anniversary of the open source project Consul Democracy (...). From 2015 onwards the Consul Democracy citizen participation platform has spread across the globe to countries as diverse as Brasil, Mexico, Scotland, Germany, Romania and, more recently, Somalia and the Maldives." The conference addresses topics related to digital [...]
International Democratic Education Conference - IDEC@EUDEC 2025 
Belgium
Beginning 01.08.2025
The organisers of the conference understand democratic education to mean, on the one hand, the right of children and young people to make their own choices regarding learning and all other areas of daily life; and, on the other hand, that children and young people have an equal share in decision-making about how their organisations – in particular their schools [...]
National Summit on Civic Education (USA) 
United States of America
Beginning 18.05.2025
The National Summit on Civic Education is an annual event organised by the nonprofit educational organisation Jack Miller Center (USA). Participation in the summit is by invitation only. It is aimed at "leading representatives of civic education" from various political perspectives. The last meeting in 2024 brought together 170 participants. The 2024 summit was also [...]
Annual Civic Education Conference (ACEC) 
Indonesia
Beginning 04.11.2024
The Annual Civic Education Conference (ACEC) is usually held annually by the Indonesia Association of Pancasila and Civic Education Profession (IAPCEP). The theme of the conference is civic education, political education and democracy education. Since 2018, there have been five conferences, focusing on the following topics:2018: Strenghtening National and Global [...]
Our week for "Citizenship and Democracy - let's do it together"

Further relevant dossiers on democracy education worldwide
News worldwide
- Anti-Semitism as a pretext? Columbia University pays 1 million to US government (DLF 25.07.25) [courtesy translation]
- Due to the current situation: Summer camps in the USA
- New dossier from Education Worldwide on homeschooling and compulsory education in an international perspective
- How educational technologists support schools in Estonia (Dt. Schulportal23.06.25) [courtesy translation]